Best Italian Restaurants in Burlington
Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars
Burlington's Italian dining scene is a delightful surprise that punches well above its weight for a city of its size. From family-run trattorias serving recipes passed down through generations to modern Italian kitchens putting creative spins on classics, this charming Vermont city has cultivated an authentic Italian food culture that rivals much larger metropolitan areas. The secret lies in the passionate chefs and restaurateurs who've made Burlington home, bringing with them the soul of Italian cooking while embracing the fresh, local ingredients that Vermont is famous for. Burlington's Italian restaurants deliver with remarkable consistency and heart.
This guide showcases 10 exceptional Italian establishments, each earning stellar ratings of 4.5 stars or higher from hundreds of satisfied diners. We've spent months sampling everything from intimate neighborhood gems to bustling kitchen bars, evaluating not just the food but the entire experience – the warmth of service, the authenticity of flavors, and that intangible magic that makes a meal memorable. These aren't just restaurants; they're destinations where every bite tells a story of Italian tradition meeting Vermont hospitality.
Featured Restaurants
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar delivers authentic Italian flavors in a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere that has won over nearly 5,000 diners with its impressive 4.7-star rating. Travelers consistently rave about the generous portions, fresh ingredients, and lively bar scene that makes it perfect for both casual dinners and celebratory meals. With convenient takeaway and delivery options available, it's an excellent choice if you're dining in or enjoying their Italian classics from your hotel.
Pizzeria Verità
This beloved Burlington hotspot has earned its stellar reputation with nearly a thousand glowing reviews, drawing both locals and visitors with its inviting bar atmosphere and consistently excellent food. Travelers rave about the quality and authenticity that keeps them coming back, making it worth visiting destination in Vermont's foodie scene. Arrive early or be prepared to wait, as this popular spot fills up quickly thanks to its well-deserved reputation for delivering an outstanding dining experience.
Di Mario’s Trattoria
Di Mario's Trattoria has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with nearly 800 glowing reviews praising its warm, authentic Italian atmosphere and consistently excellent food. The restaurant's impressive 4.6-star rating speaks to its ability to deliver memorable dining experiences, from classic pasta dishes to expertly prepared entrees that keep guests coming back. Reserve ahead for weekend dinners, as this Burlington gem fills up quickly with diners who've discovered why it's considered one of the area's top dining destinations.
Trattoria Delia
This beloved Burlington gem draws locals and visitors alike with its warm, welcoming atmosphere and expertly prepared dishes that showcase culinary diversity at its finest. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from nearly 600 reviews, Trattoria Delia has clearly mastered the art of consistent, memorable dining experiences that keep people coming back. Book ahead for dinner service, as this popular spot on St Paul Street fills up quickly, especially on weekends.
Paradiso
Paradiso lives up to its heavenly name with a diverse menu that caters to every palate, earning an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 500 satisfied diners who rave about the consistently delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. This Burlington gem has clearly mastered the art of pleasing crowds, making it a reliable choice as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors in the know.
Prego's Trattoria
Prego's Trattoria brings authentic Italian warmth to Burlington with its cozy atmosphere and diverse menu that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 400 reviews, diners consistently praise the generous portions, friendly service, and consistently delicious food that won't break the bank. Make reservations for weekend dinners when this popular neighborhood gem fills up quickly with families and couples alike.
Fiorella's Cucina
Fiorella's Cucina has earned a devoted following with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that keeps diners coming back, as evidenced by nearly 240 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.5-star rating. Travelers consistently praise this Burlington gem for its reliable quality and variety, making it a safe bet consider visiting during off-peak hours when you can fully enjoy the attentive service that reviewers rave about.
Culinary Experiences in Burlington
Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences